×
× Digital News Videos Opinion Special Reports Lifestyle Central Coast Eastern Nairobi North Eastern Nyanza Rift Valley Western Business News Stocks Financial Standard Africa Asia America Europe Weird News Editorial Commentary Letters Crazy World Features Entertainment Money & Careers Health & Science Sci & Tech Home & Away Generation Next Cartoon Education Pointblank Environment Travel & Destination Columns Kipkoech Tanui uReport Kiambu Murang'a Nyandarua Kirinyaga Nyeri Baringo Bomet Elgeyo Kajiado Kericho Laikipia Nakuru Nandi Narok Samburu Trans Nzoia Turkana Mombasa Kwale Kilifi Tanariver Taita Taveta Kakamega Vihiga Bungoma Busia Siaya Kisumu Homabay Migori Kisii Nyamira Nairobi Uasin Gishu West Pokot Sunday Magazine The Hague Trial Kenya @ 50 Education and Training Health and Environment Insurance and Financial Security Housing Current Affairs Humour Makau Mutua David Oginde Clay Muganda Comand Your Morning Mohamed Wehliye Wednesday Life Alexander Chagema Arts & Culture Kamotho Waiganjo Barrack Muluka Xn Iraki Urban Rights - By Steve Ouma Branding Voice KCB Fredrick Ogola Sunday Magazine Wanja Kavengi Njoki Kaigai David Oginde Ken Opalo Daisy Maritim Houghton Irungu Hustle News Group Stages Round of 16 Quarter Finals Semi Finals Finals Third Place play-offs Opinion Dr Pesa Podcasts Round Table Sepetuko Eve Woman Ramadhan Special Fact Check Correction Explainers The Standard Insider Blog E-Paper Lifestyle & Entertainment Nairobian Entertainment Eve Woman Travelog TV Stations KTN Home KTN News BTV KTN Farmers TV Radio Stations Radio Maisha Spice FM Vybez Radio Enterprise VAS E-Learning Digger Classified The Standard Group Corporate Contact Us Rate Card Vacancies DCX O.M Portal Corporate Email RMS
×

The call for secession is premature, unnecessary, shelve it

By James Aggrey Mwamu | August 25th 2017 at 12:00:00 GMT +0300

(Photo Courtesy)

The secession debate has been raging for the past few days.

It is a debate that has been created by people who feel that two regions in Kenya have lorded it over them for a long time.

It is a debate that sounds very dangerous to some but to me it sounds very attractive and romantic. In certain parts of our country, the debate seems to be attaining some messianic tone and an aura of de javu.

The time for liberation has come.

This is partly because they feel disenfranchised and oppressed by a hostile government.

The secession debate is healthy and as a country we need to confront these things.

After all both the United Nations Charter and Africa Charter on Human and People’s Rights recognise a people’s right to self-determination.

A number of scholars have however found the UN charter self-contradictory.

The preamble of the United Nations’ Charter (UN Charter) declares that justice and respect for international law and the international community is to be maintained.

The core principle of international law delineated in the UN Charter is that a state’s territorial integrity is inviolable.

However, the UN also enforces nation states’ obligations to their citizens by granting individuals the right of self-determination.

The right of self-determination refers to a group of individuals’ ability to make “choices free from the force of the institutional framework within which they live”.

Secession often takes a violent struggle to achieve. Secession occurs when persons in a country or state declare their independence from the ruling government.

Violent struggle

When a dissatisfied group secedes, it creates its own form of government in place of the former ruling government. Secessions are serious manoeuvres that lead to, or arise from, military conflict.

The lack of specific international law guiding rights of self-determination and protecting nations’ territorial integrity has contributed to unnecessary chaos and conflicts.

The UN Charter must be reformed to include a legal framework with detailed guidelines for secession movements and corresponding accountability measures.

In Kenya, calls for secession are not new. In 1998, former President Kibaki, while accompanied by a group of MPs from central Kenya, called for secession and formation of a new State to include Laikipia, Nakuru, Meru, Embu and Central Kenya. They viewed Moi’s government as oppressive, tyrannical and lacking legitimacy and the right to govern.

President Kibaki became President and all calls for secession were buried with his electoral victory in 2002. He ruled for 10years and handed over power calling for Kenya to remain a unitary state.

In February 2003, 14 Rift Valley MPs reeling from the acts of the Kibaki Government, which they considered oppressive and tyrannical, called for the formation of Rift Valley State. The calls for formation of Rift Valley State ended when William Ruto became the Deputy President of the Republic of Kenya.

Healthy debate?

Secession debate is healthy but it must not be carried out in a manner that diminishes the weighty issues we face as a country and whether there are no other options left.

It is hardly seven years since we passed a new constitution. Are we openly admitting that the new constitution has failed? Are we saying that the new constitution has been hijacked and watered down by powerful cartels? Are the issues being raised incapable of being sorted out under a new constitution.

Does the creation of two or three states help us a country? Have we counted the cost of secession? Is Kenya becoming a failed state? A scholar by the name Nicola Pijovic has written an article about Somali Land titled “Seceding but not Succeeding”.

This is a story about Somaliland and its failure to gain regional and international recognition.

The United States Civil War was the biggest and the most serious struggle for secession in the history of United States and the world.

In February 1861, South Carolina seceded from the Union, and Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, Texas, Arkansas, and Tennessee followed suit shortly thereafter.

These states seceded because they objected to attempts by the federal government to abolish the enslavement of black people. The mass secession led to four years of civil war and the death of hundreds of thousands of people.

The seceding states established their own government called the Confederate States of America and fought the US military forces with their own army. When the confederate forces were defeated in April 1865, the seceding states rejoined the United States.

Whereas these debates are healthy, let us strive to strengthen devolution of resources and power.

Let’s address the weaknesses in our Constitution, which includes asking ourselves whether a pure presidential system serves our needs or still promotes the big-man syndrome or political patronage.

If the current constitution totally fails to work for us and keep us together, then the debate will become meaningful. This secession debate is premature and unhelpful in my humble view.

Mr Mwamu is an Advocate of the High Court of Kenya and a former President of East Africa Law Society


secession president uhuru kenyatta Raila Odinga Canaan
Share this story

Read More

Feedback