Justice Ndung'u's opinion left a sour taste for justice
| Sep 25th 2017 | 2 min read
The Supreme Court's landmark ruling that nullified the August 8 presidential results continue to reverberate across the continent and globally. As the court continues to receive an accolades and criticism in equal measure from across the political divide, one important factor that stands out conspicuously and has serious implications not only on the Supreme Court but Kenya’s judicial operations as a whole, is the dissenting judgement by Justice Njoki Ndung'u. Dissenting opinions are key and give judges an opportunity to give reasons why they disagreed with the majority. This opinion can then help the majority clarify their position.
A dissent opinion in the Supreme Court, which is the last resort in the land, can also be used as an appeal where the minority feel that the decision taken by the majority goes against the law and hopes that a similar decision in the future ruling will be different when their arguments are taken into consideration. However, Ms Ndung'u's dissenting opinion failed to serve the purpose and instead eroded her credibility and squeezed out of her the value and the esteem bestowed on her as the officer of the court. While reading her judgement, she openly demonstrated anger and bitterness with the majority ruling. In fact, the choice of language and harsh criticism of the Chief Justice over affirmation that the court would not hesitate to annul any other election if not conducted according to the dictates of the Constitution, her intonation almost bordered on intolerance, which I believe is a vice rather than a virtue for a practicing judge.
Hero’s welcome for Cheruiyot: Hundreds attend homecoming party in BometHe had an outstanding performance in IAAF World Championship and Diamond League.
When Njonjo almost resigned over coffee smugglersKnown as the era of black gold, it began in 1976 when Ugandan farmers decided to sell their coffee in the private market.
Why Uhuru will not be part of Azimio campaign trail- Murathe
- Accept polls outcome in August, Uhuru tells aspirants
By Brian Okoth
- What the design of Pension Towers symbolises.
- If Kalonzo chooses to work with Raila, I'll support him, says Andrew Sunkuli
By Mate Tongola
- Former Runyenjes MP denies links to viral post on running mate
- Ruto catches Karua by surprise as he breaks protocol
By Betty Njeru