Looming legal battle as Senate to craft a bill to guard sitting governors

Senators are planning a bill that will shield governors from criminal and civil proceedings while in office, Nandi Senator Samson Cherargei has said.

Mr Cherargei (pictured), who spoke during an interview, said the bill is meant to change the constitution to give immunity to county chiefs against any form of prosecution.

Cherargei is also Senate's Legal Affairs and Human rights committee chairman. 

SEE ALSO :BBI: Senators in new push to outrank MPs

“Just like the President and his deputy are protected from any form of prosecution while in office, governors should not be charged until when they are out of office,” said Cherargei.

The Senate's actions come on the back of a ruling by Court of Appeal judge Mumbi Ngugi who asserted that governors facing graft charges should not set foot in their offices until the cases are concluded.

Cherargei argued that the prosecution of sitting governors was killing devolution since governors, just like the president, make executive decisions of importance to counties.

Love in times of COVID-19 - The Standard  

“This bill should not be mistaken to mean that we condone corruption. All we want is for services at the counties to continue uninterpreted even when governors are being investigated," he said.

"Let governors be pursued and charged after they leave office. The constitutional amendment will only give immunity to the county bosses at the time they are in office.”

SEE ALSO :Senators pay glowing tribute to Moi

Cherargei also averred that the fight for governor's immunity has been motivated by the fact that some prosecutions are being mooted to settle political scored.

 “We do not want a scenario where county bosses are victimised for failing to tow a certain political line," the Nandi senator said. 

"The fight against corruption should not be used to settle political scores or intimidate governors.”

Cherargei stressed that the recent Court of Appeal decision to bar governors facing graft charges from accessing office is setting a dangerous precedence.

“Devolution is under attack from the Judiciary, rogue MCAs, National Treasury and the Executive,” he said.

SEE ALSO :Shield our local contractors from competition - Senators

Ridiculous proposals

However, senators Moses Wetangula (Bungoma), Fatuma Dullo (Isiolo), Mohammed Faki (Mombasa), Mutula Kilonzo Jrn (Makueni), Johnson Sakaja (Nairobi) and Isaac Mwaura (Nominated) have declared their opposition to the bill.

The lawmakers described the proposal to shield governors from prosecution as ridiculous and vowed to reject it.

“This proposal is ridiculous since no one is above the law apart from the president. We shall resist the attempt in the Senate,” said Mr Sakaja.

He added that leaders should be ready to account for their actions while in the office so long as the law is followed when prosecuting them.

Mr Mutula, who is a member of the Justice, Legal Affairs and Human Rights Committee, said those who wrote the constitution had a reason to limit immunity to only the president.

“The immunity enjoyed by the president is not shared with the deputy president for a good reason," Mutula said. 

Overseen plunder

Governors Mike Sonko (Nairobi), Ferdinand Waititu (Kiambu) and Moses Lenolkulal (Samburu) have all been barred from accessing office after being charged with corruption.

Mr Faki said the bill would necessitate a constitutional amendment. He said many county chiefs have overseen plunder in their devolved governments and should not be protected.

“With the hue and cry being raised over misappropriation of funds by governors, we cannot accept such a provision," said Faki.

"It will make it very difficult for the Senate to hold governors to account.”

Do not miss out on the latest news. Join the Standard Digital Telegram channel HERE.

Get the latest summary of news in your email every morning. Subscribe below

* indicates required
SenatorsSamson CherargeiGovernorsImmunity