✕

Political freedom and test of Kenyan democracy

Columnists
By Wanja Maina | Nov 15, 2026

Barack Obama and Uhuru Kenyatta have more in common than their former positions as presidents. Both were born in 1961, just 83 days apart. Both are left-handed and served two presidential terms. Yet their experiences after leaving office offer an interesting perspective on how democracies accommodate former leaders who remain politically active.

In the November 2026 midterm elections, the Democrats in the US regained control of both chambers of Congress. Obama was not on the ballot, but he was actively involved in the campaigns. He endorsed candidates, recorded campaign advertisements, attended fundraising events and reportedly raised $13.6 million for Democratic committees. His contribution was part of a wider campaign shaped by voters' concerns and the political circumstances of the day. Still, his involvement demonstrated that leaving the presidency does not mean becoming politically irrelevant.

The American and Kenyan political systems are different, and there is no reason Kenya must copy the US model. But the comparison raises an important question: why does Uhuru's continued participation in political conversations attract so much resistance?

Since leaving office in 2022, Uhuru has repeatedly been reminded that he is retired. Politicians have urged him to leave politics, enjoy his retirement and conduct himself like a former head of state.

In May 2026, a motion was tabled in Senate seeking to withdraw, reduce or reallocate Uhuru's retirement benefits on account of his alleged continued involvement in partisan politics. The matter became even more contentious when other political leaders publicly called for his pension to be withdrawn if he continued participating in politics. This was no longer simply a disagreement about whether a former president should remain politically active.

Article 151(3) of the Constitution protects a former president's retirement benefits from being varied to their disadvantage during their lifetime. This protection should not depend on whether a former officeholder agrees with the government of the day.

The law makes an important distinction. Section 6(1) of the Presidential Retirement Benefits Act restricts a retired president from holding formal office in a political party beyond six months after leaving office. It does not expressly prohibit political speech, criticism of government or participation in public debate.

The courts have also differed on the provision. Justice Lawrence Mugambi upheld the restriction on holding formal party office, while on September 21, 2026, Justice Bahati Mwamuye declared Section 6 unconstitutional and void. The conflicting decisions underline the need to distinguish between regulating formal party leadership and protecting an individual's wider constitutional rights.

Articles 33, 36 and 38 of the Constitution protect freedom of expression, association and political participation. These protections should not become dependent on whether a former officeholder agrees with the government of the day.

The issue returned to public attention on November 11, when Uhuru attended a memorial service for his cousin, Wambui Muturi, where opposition leaders including were present. He urged them to put aside personal ambitions and unite ahead of the 2027 General Election. Explaining why he remained interested in the country's affairs, he made a simple but telling observation: "Retiring does not mean that my ears don't listen."

President William Ruto responded by questioning the source of Uhuru's views, urging him to seek opinions from sober people rather than those he associated with local drinking places. He also accused him of sponsoring the opposition.

The President is entitled to disagree with Uhuru's assessment of public opinion. But the exchange shifted attention from the substance of the former president's argument to the circumstances in which he gathered his views. Whether opposition unity reflects the wishes of Kenyans is a legitimate political question. It deserves an equally substantive response.

None of this places Uhuru beyond criticism. His administration's record, public debt, economic decisions and political alliances remain legitimate subjects of public scrutiny. Defending his right to political expression does not require defending his presidential record.

Kenya's political parties must also learn to outlive the personalities who build them. They need internal democracy, credible succession mechanisms and institutions strong enough to make decisions without depending on the influence of former leaders.

Leaving the presidency means surrendering executive authority, not citizenship. Kenyans must hear a former president, challenge his or her arguments and hold him accountable.

Share this story
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS