In the first part of ‘The unwanted twin’, we reported about the long-term abuse of six year old, Alika, a girl from the Oshwal Community.
Today, Alika’s parents speak out, but their identities have been concealed to protect their daughter.
“I can recall very well that on 10th June 2010, I was blessed with two daughters – Aliya* and Alika*. After giving birth, Alika was a premature baby; she was kept in the incubator for 22 days” she wrote in her police statement, painting the picture of a child who had a very rough start to her life.
The next key incident that she notes down being one that will likely affect Alika as long as she lives. “At 10 months she fell from (the) sofa-set, she was injured her left side of the brain which resulted in the right side of her body getting paralysed. At the same time, the doctor responded that she was epileptic...”
The parents went on to describe a three-year period within which Alika was taken to India to live with her grandmother, as her and her young husband couldn’t cope with the bills they would receive for her treatment in Kenya.
In India, Alika is said to have made significant progress in her physiotherapy and overall development, so she was brought back to live with her family.
She would be enrolled in an Oshwal run school, but according to her parents, Alika couldn’t cope with the pace of the other students, and was withdrawn.
Bijal Shah, the headmistress of the school that Alika was taken to, says that she would later find out that Alika was allegedly withdrawn because the school’s management started asking questions about the strange wounds she would come to school bearing.
Alika’s injuries, she alleges, were noted within the first month of her attending Bijal’s school. The pictures that she took, Bijal alleges, were just part of the story.
“In the midst of all this, Alika from day one at school continuously asked everyone using signs and gestures and asking verbally “food, food.”
In her statement, Bijal makes note of a record she allegedly kept of the meals that Alika was sent to school with, also claiming that she raised it with Alika’s mother.
“I talked to mother about increasing the quantity of Alika’s break-time snack. She responded that she had no time to pack extra” before Bijal and Alika’s parents traded accusations over who was responsible for Alika’s injuries, with Bijal consistently stating how many times she reached out to the Oshwal Education Relief Board, without success, until April 27, 2015.
It had been four months since Bijal had first reported the injuries to a member of the Oshwal Committee.
Minutes kept by Bijal describe members of the Oshwal Education Relief Board being shocked at the photos of Alika that were presented to them. However, as she notes in the minutes, “Nothing came of the meeting”. Later though, the community would broker a temporary settlement, where a relative of Alika’s parents would take her for a month.
Nine days after this, the relative contacted the Oshwal Committee asking to return the child to her parents. Bijal alleges that this relative says he was “under pressure” from Alika’s parents to return her, but Alika’s mother claims that there was no such pressure.
When Bijal heard that Alika would be returned to her parents, she claims that she got very upset, and began pushing for that not to happen.
It wasn’t until consistent pushing by Bijal, and an alleged threat to take the information she had to the police that Bijal says the Oshwal Education Relief Board invited her to an emergency session. This time though, the Chairman of the Hindu Council of Kenya, Nitin Malde, was present.
Malde is a well-known businessman in the community, and is said to have deep networks in Kenya’s business and political classes.
According to her statement and minutes taken of that meeting, Bijal says she fought for three hours for the board not to return Alika to her parents. Members of the board, who had seen the photos of the child’s injuries, she claims, kept silent.
“I then declared that I would report this matter to the Children’s Department and the police. That is when the Chairman of the Hindu Council of Kenya Nitin Malde threatened to shut down my school and imprison me if I were to inform the Children’s Department or the police,” Bijal claims. She continues:
“He claimed that His Excellency the President Honourable Uhuru Kenyatta was his personal friend so I should watch out.”
Confronted by this writer on phone, Nitin Malde said “I did not say anything like that. I have written a statement of what happened and I did not say that. These are complete lies.”
An individual who was at this meeting, who did not want us to reveal their name for fear of reprisals, said the following of the meeting.
“It was a meeting where it was unpleasant.”
Was Bijal threatened? I asked.
“Threatened is a strong word. I t was sort of a condition. If you don’t do this, this will happen.”
“Did Nitin Malde say that he and President Kenyatta were personal friends and that she should watch out?”
“I faintly recollect something to that effect. He said something like “I can put you in trouble.”
After the meeting, Alika was taken back to her parents, the abuse continued.
“On the 22nd of June Alika came to school with a swollen and bruised palm. An imprint of the heel of a shoe was visible,” she writes.
“On the 25th of June Alika came to school with a busted lip, a swollen forehead and bruises on the face. I could not take this any more.”
Bijal claims that she wrote to Alika’s parents, asking them to withdraw her from the school.
Alika’s parents deny claims of abuse repeatedly through their statements, expressing shock and dismay at the claims, but by this time, word in the school had gone round about Alika’s alleged abuse.
One family in particular, the Mehta’s*, were particularly moved by the plight of this young girl, and made an application to the Children’s Department to have her removed from her parents’ custody the police in casual clothes, the people from the court and the media came to our house on 9th July at around 3:30pm and took Alika* away.”
Her husband’s statement of the events of that day read similarly; not giving away any hint of what they felt.
