Video assistant referees - the case for and against

[Photo:courtesy]

Video assistant referees (VARs) have been trialled in recent international friendlies and are currently being used at the Confederations Cup in Russia.

Portugal had an early effort controversially disallowed by the video referees during their 2-2 draw with Mexico on Sunday afternoon- according to rtesoccer

Defender Pepe thought he had opened the scoring in the 21st minute when he turned in a cross-shot after Cristiano Ronaldo had smashed a shot against the crossbar, having blasted his initial free-kick into the defensive wall.

However, Argentinian referee Nestor Pitana called for a review from the VAR and it was eventually ruled that Pepe was one of four players who were offside from Joao Moutinho's first cross into the box following the failed set-piece.

There was more controversy in the evening kick-off between Chile and Cameroon.

Eduardo Vargas thought he'd put the Chileans ahead in the first half but, after some deliberation, the VAR judged he'd been in an offside position when he raced on to a through ball and slotted home.

Chile coach Juan Antonio Pizzi believes more time is needed for new technology to be understood after his team felt the positive and negative results of the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system being tested at the Confederations Cup in Russia.

“I think this system needs time. If I understand it correctly, we are trialling the system right now and there are maybe doubts because we are used to other situations in football," said Pizzi.

“I think we have to wait and see and maybe as we start getting use to it, it will get better,” he told a news conference after the opening Group B game.

“Having our goal at the end of the first half disallowed created stress for the players because they were not used to such a situation. But, on the otter hand, technology in the end will probably mean more justice in the game.

“The only negative about today’s incident with the VAR was that it is difficult for the players focusing in the game to absorb, and even if it is the right decision it has an impact on their psyche.”

Arturo Vidal, who had protested to the match officials, had this to say after the match "It's the first time we have played with this new technology and it's true while out on the pitch you are concentrating so that when it happens against you, it's difficult to comprehend.”

Under the VAR system, the referee can communicate with two video assistant referees sitting in a room in the stadium with access to all camera channels.

They look at goals scored, penalties awarded, straight red cards and cases of mistaken identity, when a player given a yellow or red card is not actually involved in an incident.

The VARs are allowed to correct the referee while the match official can refer decisions to them for a review.

Football's law-making body IFAB is expected to decide in March whether to authorise the use of VARs on a permanent basis.

Next Story
LATEST STORIES
Man City offer 'Sergio Aguero in swap deal for Alexis Sanchez'

Manchester City are refusing to give up on primary summer transfer target Alexis Sanchez and are reportedly ready to go to extreme lengths to get their man.

Chelsea to set new transfer record by signing Alex Sandro and Tiemoue Bakayoko

Chelsea are poised to make Alex Sandro the world’s most expensive defender this week as they launch a £100million double deal.

Arsenal's Mesut Ozil, Leicester’s Ahmed Musa among stars across Europe to celebrate Eid

Following the end of Ramadan, Premier League footballers and those from across Europe have been celebrating Eid.

Kenya's cricket lords keep dropping catches

It has been a week of hits and misses, and one of the misses was on a personal level: I did not pen this column last Monday because I was on the road.

Boxing: Okoth makes Africa bouts final

National lightweight champion Nick Okoth defeated Hamout Mohammed of Mauritius to sail through to the final of the African Boxing Championships in Congo Brazzaville on Saturday night.

Young athletes dazzle at Nyayo: Cyrus Ruto gives good account of himself in 5,000m

Youngsters prove they are ready to dine with kings and queens.

More Stories
Tennis-Federer demolishes Zverev to win ninth Halle title

World number five Roger Federer delivered a tennis masterclass to beat rising star Alexander Zverev 6-1 6-3 and clinch a record ninth Halle Open title on Sunday as he lay down a marker in the lead-up to Wimbledon.

Gotv Shield Cup: Bondo Utd falls to Nzoia Sugar

Nzoia United pipped Bondo United FC 2-0 during the round of 64 of Gotv Shield Cup at Moi Stadium, Kisumu yesterday.

Chile into semis after draw with profligate Australia

Chile reached the Confederations Cup semi-finals on Sunday with a 1-1 draw against Australia, who muscled the South Americans out of their stride but exited the tournament after wasting their chances.

Germany reach semis as referee needs VAR double-take

Germany eased into the Confederations Cup semi-finals with a 3-1 win over Cameroon on Sunday as the VAR system was again thrust into the spotlight when the on-field official needed two reviews of an incident to reach the right verdict.

Loic Remy to leave Chelsea this summer

Forgotten man Loic Remy is set to be sold for a cut price fee.

Ronaldo sets Portugal on way to Confederations Cup semis after win over New Zealand

European champions Portugal comfortably dispatched New Zealand 4-0 to reach the Confederations Cup semi-finals on Saturday after Cristiano Ronaldo set them on their way with a penalty.

Mexico knock out Confederations Cup hosts Russia

Mexico winger Hirving Lozano took advantage of an awful mix-up in the Russian defence to score an extraordinary goal which gave his side a 2-1 win and knocked the Confederations Cup hosts out of the tournament on Saturday.

Rooney struggling to find a new club

Wayne Rooney faces being stuck on the bench at Old Trafford next season with Manchester United unwilling to fund a cut-price exit.

Chelsea eye Juve pair

Antonio Conte is going back to plunder his former stomping ground, if you believe reports coming out of Italy.