Ranguma case dealt a big blow as court dismiss application for vote recount
| Nov 17th 2017 | 3 min read
Former Kisumu Governor Jack Ranguma suffered a blow after a court dismissed his application for a vote recount.
High Court Judge David Majanja, in a five-minute ruling on Thursday, termed the application broad, vague and lacking specific terms.
The judge pointed out that Ranguma’s petition challenging the election of Peter Anyang' Nyong'o was premised on the inconsistencies of the results recorded in the physical forms 37A, against those transmitted in the Kenya Integrated Electoral Management Systems (KIEMS), on which he had already granted orders for scrutiny.
No clear basis
However, the same judge who ordered for the scrutiny of the electronic voter transmission system three weeks ago, yesterday disagreed with Ranguma on the re-opening of all the ballot boxes to have the votes recounted, arguing that no clear basis was laid for the application to warrant an order for the same.
“I have considered the submissions and the law, and I find that the petitioner’s application for scrutiny suffers a congenital birth defect, as the petition affidavit does not specify which polling stations require further scrutiny,” said Majanja, maintaining the law and precedents provided for specificity in application for scrutiny of ballot boxes.
He added: “The necessity to identify polling station is emphasised, in previous similar judgements, that application for scrutiny and recount must be carved in specific terms and clothed with particularity as to which polling stations within a constituency are to attract such scrutiny, otherwise a blanket scrutiny cannot be entertained.”
Ranguma, who wants election of Nyong’o overturned, had in the application sought to have scrutiny of all the 1,027 ballot boxes used in the election, arguing that his agents reported widespread malpractices across the county.
He also claimed the inconsistencies witnessed in the physical result declaration forms and those transmitted through the KIEMS exposed irregularities could have cost him his win.
Through his lawyer Richard Onsongo, Ranguma had claimed the adulteration of samples of the statutory forms, backed by corroborating testimonies of the petitioner's witnesses was a clear ground to order for total scrutiny of ballots.
Majanja, however, pointed out that that the dismissal did not amount to the end of the case, as he hinted at granting an order for scrutiny of specific ballot boxes should IEBC, which is set to argue its case in a fortnight, fail to defend their numbers in areas where inconsistencies were pointed out.
“I am aware that at this stage I am not required to make a definitive determination of finding on the petitioner’s case as the respondents are yet to make their case. I am, however, not convinced that at this stage it would be appropriate to make the order sought, perhaps the examinations and cross-examinations of the respondent’s witnesses, and more particularly the returning officer may convince me to act suo moto (without further application from another party),” said Majanja.
At least 15 IEBC witnesses, who include County Returning Officer John Cox, are set to take to the dock between November 29 and December 1, to testify in support of the declaration of Nyong’o win.
And Majanja said Ranguma counsel will have an opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses.
The judge, however, ordered Ranguma to bear the cost of the dismissed application, while hinting that the results of KIEMS scrutiny will remain as provisional, as final results remain as recorded in the original forms 37A.
NASA cat and mouse game with policeEmbakasi East MP Babu Owino, his Ruaraka counterpart TJ Kajwang and Starehe politician Steve Mbogo were arrested as Opposition leaders engaged police in a cat-and-mouse game.
When Njonjo almost resigned over coffee smugglersKnown as the era of black gold, it began in 1976 when Ugandan farmers decided to sell their coffee in the private market.
Six KNH employees in court for allegedly stealing Sh4.68m cancer drugs
HEALTH & SCIENCE
By Mate Tongola
- Karua vs Rigathi
- 'Samuel Mugota took care of me well', one of two new women tells police
By Kamore Maina
- Give Kithi an appointive seat, let me run for Kilifi Governor, Jumwa to Ruto
By Brian Okoth
- John Githongo to pay Murungaru Sh10m over Anglo Leasing
- Suspect drove getaway car after Mirema shooting: DCI
By Paul Ogemba